Categories

THE CORRECT OPINION: The Robert Matthew Harp EP

THE CORRECT OPINION: The Robert Matthew Harp EP

Dannon Walker and Elias Callen



Ohhhhhhh Boy What A T-t-treat! This month we will be covering TWO releases for our audience of Mrs. Kowalske because Elias Callen didn’t write their section of the article on time (sorry -Elias) so we had to post it on November 4th instead of October 31st or whatever. This month we’ll be looking at The Heatherton Heatwave’s debut EP and only release, The Robert Matthew Harp EP, which you’ll read about in just a few seconds. Later this month we’ll be looking at mathgrind’s prodigal child, Destroyer Destroyer, and their LP Littered With Arrows. I’m sure it will be a delight to read. We are covering my favorite “core” genre here, so if you don’t like this I’m gonna be so sad. Also, we rank EPs on a scale of five instead of ten thankssss.

Yours lovelyly,

 Dannon Walker


I hate mathcore.

And I’m not really sorry for being late. And go listen to the EP; it's at THE BOTTOM now. 

Most greedily,  

Elias Jerome (‘s dream) “The Dreamer”  “Jererome” “J-rome” “The Whizzard” “Knife Monster” Callen


Mostly recognized as a glimpse of what was yet to come, The Heatherton Heatwave was a very short lived New York Not-City based mathcore band that performed from the late 90s to early 2000s. Because of the band’s rather short stint and a relative lack of information, I can’t hand over a lot of details. What I can tell you, though, is that their lineup was prestigious, including John Karel of such famous bands as The Sawtooth Grin and The Number 12 Looks Like You, as well as Christopher Lombardi. He is the brother of Rich Lombardi, also of The Sawtooth Grin. Yeah. Okay. The Sawtooth Grin.

Elias

Mathcore has always been something that I never really understood, and after listening to The Robert Matthew Harp EP, I still don’t understand it but I know it sounds powerful when Amato gives those strained screams over the dance-twinkle of the very signature mathcore guitar riffs. To me, the guitar is the highlight of this album, both in style and in general sonic attitude. Mathcore itself relies heavily on the varied sound of the and combination of different time signatures (that is what makes it “math-y” in the first place), and The Heatherton Heatwave bends this kind of combination effectively to make a distinct sounding character. To a simple minded stone like me (Elias  Jerome [‘s dream] “The Dreamer”  “Jererome” “J-rome” “The Whizzard” “Knife Monster” Callen) mathcore can end up sounding sort of similar and nondescript in between bands, but The Heatherton Heatwave is able to really push these boundaries. In my favorite song, the 12 minute 28 second “The Utopian Foxtrot,” the band switches between a clean tone and a thumpy distortion, sometimes incorporating both at the same time. Trying to keep me engaged with any kind of clean toned guitar is a task comparable to that given to those unfortunate souls forced to drink a golden calf for not following God’s word, before Moses even came down from the mountain with the Ten Commandments (Exodus 32:20); that is to say, seemingly impossible. But The Heatherton Heatwave managed to do it, unlike Moses, who failed to save those bovine believers from eternal damnation. This however is not to say that this is a Buddy Holly record or easy listening to the average, not-yet degenerate ears, as it still has the bite and the chutzpah like any of the hardcore subgenres.  

I think that The Robert Matthew Harp EP is an EP that can be enjoyed both by those committed mathcore fans, as well as people who are looking for a kind of a gateway drug into the most ridiculously awful time signatures ever to be played. The songs are catchy and I find myself coming back to it when I can’t really decide what I want to listen to.  There isn’t really an unpleasant song or one I would skip, and my only complaint is that they included one interlude song without taking the idea to a full length LP. I don’t think I hate mathcore anymore. 4/5.  

Dannon

In all honesty, this review is very difficult to write, and not just because I’m doing it on my phone. Usually there’s a slew of information about a band, or at least some. The Heatherton Heatwave, despite my love for the band, has largely snuck past the public eye and has very little information about them available. In the age of the web! How else am I supposed to validate my opinions??!! I need approval!!

I find The Heatherton Heatwave and The Robert Matthew Harp EP  predominantly slipping between the traditional pile of mathy-grindy-metallic nonsense, almost emulating the era’s titans— namely Botch and The Dillinger Escape Plan— and an interesting melodic and danceable sass. I feel off about dumbing the record down to two styles, though. The work is so varied in aesthetic and ambience throughout that I find it hard to pin down. Obviously there are more conventional aspects, the vocals and some of the more angular guitar riffs off the first half come to mind, but The Heatherton Heatwave as a whole I find nearly impossible to place. “The Utopia Foxtrot” almost feels like a mathcore ballad, thirteen minutes long and not a second wasted. It’s a track very focused on ambiance with a few lively sections, a rarity in the genre. The progression of the guitar in “Chalk it Up To The Customs of the Inuit” is very interesting, parts compounding on themselves and being abandoned nearly as fast as picked up. I don’t think there’s a dropped ball on the EP, but the standout track is “Science Fiction Fiasco” by far. It’s almost climactic when compared to other songs in the genre, and the mathy element is perfectly melded with sass and the hardcore elements.  The call and response bit, as well as the subsequent dancey part just clicks. 

The only issue with The Robert Matthew Harp EP is that I feel it lacks the development of a main connecting mood or theme, getting samey in the beginning to the ears of a two-tour mathcore veteran.  This release is certainly an indicator of the success of The Number Twelve Looks Like You in 2003 and The Sawtooth Grin in 2004. I’m not sure I’ve fully internalized the music, and I have no idea who Robert Matthew Harp is, but I don’t see a reason I should give it anything less than a 4.5/5. If you like this, go listen to The Dillinger Escape Plan’s self-titled album. Which isn’t on Spotify. Sorry. None of this is.

Stunning, Heartbreaking, and Held Back: Reviewing Sunrise on the Reaping (Spoiler-Free & Spoiler Breakdown)

Stunning, Heartbreaking, and Held Back: Reviewing Sunrise on the Reaping (Spoiler-Free & Spoiler Breakdown)

College Commits: Keira Quigley

College Commits: Keira Quigley